From Breastfeeding to Baby Led Weaning – is your baby ready for family foods?

Around the middle of your baby’s first year, that is at about six months, your baby will start showing signs that he is ready for family foods: he will be able to sit up in a high chair or on your lap; he will have lost the tongue thrust reflex (that protects him against choking in the early months, but also means food gets thrust out of his mouth, rather than swallowed); he will be watching you closely as you eat and probably reaching for your food and he may seem to suddenly be more hungry but not satisfied by extra milk feeds.

Introducing new foods – baby led or parent feeding?

There are two main styles of introducing family foods to your baby’s diet : you can introduce foods on a spoon or your clean finger to your baby or you can simply offer him pieces of what you are eating from your own plate (as long as foods are soft and safe). Many parents choose a mixture of both baby led (letting baby feed himself ) and parent feeding (with a spoon or finger).

When to start family foods

You may be told or hear that you should start your baby on solids earlier than six months. Unless this advice comes from a medical practitioner who is caring for your baby, this isn’t a sensible decision. There is absolutely no advantage to starting solid foods earlier than around six months – there is no evidence that solid foods will help your baby sleep longer for instance and, in fact, a baby with an upset tummy is likely to be more wakeful.

Starting solids early poses a number of risks such as premature weaning and malnutrition if your baby eats too many solids and these displace milk feeds (milk will be most of your baby’s diet for the first year). Or you could increase the risk of allergies by exposing your baby to potential allergens that his tiny gut isn’t equipped to deal with: between four and seven months a baby’s intestinal lining goes through a developmental growth spurt called closure. This means that the intestinal lining becomes more selective about what to let through. This is due to increased secretion of IgA, a protein immunoglobulin that acts as a protective coating in the intestines, preventing harmful allergens from passing through the gut wall. In the early months, IgA secretion is low (although breast milk is high in IgA), allowing allergens to easily pass through the gut wall and enter the bloodstream. As these particles enter the bloodstream antibodies may be produced to them, causing an allergic reaction. So-, of course, these are valid reasons to see introducing solid foods as just that –an ‘introduction’ rather than a meal, and to wait until your baby is developmentally ready.

However you choose to introduce family foods, if you have a family history of allergies or your baby has been sensitive to foods passing through your milk, it is wise to introduce a single food at a time in increasing proportions so that you can see how it affects your baby. If he experiences any adverse reactions such as tummy discomfort, vomiting or rashes with a new food, it is best to stop that food.

Ditch rice cereal

Common infant feeding advice suggests rice cereal as a first food because it is low protein and therefore low allergenic (allergic reactions are triggered by foreign proteins). This advice started when babies were generally introduced to foods other than milk early (at around 3 or 4 months) . At this age babies are not ready to manage anything other than  runny mush, nor are their gut linings ‘closed’ to foreign molecules that may  increase sensitisation and potential allergies. This advice was (and still is), heavily promoted by baby food companies.  However, evidence based  advice from the WHO recommends: ‘As a global public health recommendation, infants should be exclusively breastfed for the first six months of life to achieve optimal growth, development and health.’

In a 2011 White Paper: Why White Rice Cereal for Babies Must Go’  Paediatrician, Dr Alan Greene, Clinical Professor at Stanford University School of Medicine warns of a potential connection between feeding babies refined cereals and obesity. He says,  “I have been studying nutrition very carefully for more than a decade now and one of the things that I have become convinced of is that white rice cereal can predispose to childhood obesity. In fact I think it is the tap root of the child obesity epidemic.”

Dr Greene advises that white rice cereal is high in calories and made of processed white flour. “The problem is that it is basically like feeding kids a spoonful of sugar.”

He also explains  that first food experiences can set babies on a path of food preferences. He says, “We know in animals that the first bite of solid food can be particularly influential. For human babies the moment of the first bite is laden with positive associations. The child has often been staring at the parents’ food choices, eager to learn what eating is all about. The child is the centre of attention at an emotionally charged moment, often with a camera capturing the event. The processed white rice flour is often mixed with breast milk or formula, giving it an even stronger positive association. Conversion of the white rice flour to glucose begins while the cereal is still in the baby’s mouth, lighting up the hard-wired preference for sweets (and the cereal is nearly 100% glucose by the time it is absorbed in the intestines).

Dr Greene says, “given this “perfect storm” of extrinsic and intrinsic factors, both initially and throughout the formative months, it is easy to see how a preference for processed refined grain products could become firmly established, and later in life, challenging to change.”

Rice cereal is very bland, so often parents mix it with stewed fruit such as apple or pears but why not simply offer your baby the fruit which is more nutritious?  Or, your breastfed baby may enjoy a small amount of ripe mashed banana as this will be sweet like the milk he is used to. However, by the time your baby is truly ready for family food (around 6 months), he will be ready to explore a variety of tastes and textures. Consider, if you are breastfeeding, he has already experienced a range of flavours passing through your breast milk.

Baby led weaning

This style of introducing family foods is simply offering your baby whole pieces of food from your own menu and allowing him to choose how much to eat, rather than pureeing or mashing ‘baby’ foods and spooning them into your baby’s mouth (and often ‘encouraging’ him to ‘eat it all up’). This has now been labelled ‘Baby Led Weaning’ because your baby will naturally set the pace at which he is ready to proceed with eating.

The main principle with baby led weaning is that you offer your baby food by either allowing her to take it from your hand (or not, as she chooses), or you simply place food such as soft fruits or cooked vegetables on her highchair and allow her to feed herself. There are no purees and no spoon feeding. The baby leads.

Proponents of baby led weaning claim the advantages of this style of baby feeding include:

  • babies get to explore taste, texture, colour and smell of foods naturally
  • it encourages independent eating
  • helps develop hand-eye coordination
  • makes fussy eating and food fights less likely because you avoid stress around meal times and pressure to ‘eat it all up’ or encouraging your child to eat when she may not want to.

For a more comprehensive look at baby led weaning, check out Pinky’s audio interview with with Gil Rapley, UK Infant Feeding Specialist, author and proponent of Baby Led Weaning.

Baby won’t eat yet?

Please don’t worry if your baby seems disinterested in eating with gusto for several months after you introduce his first tastes of solid foods. It is important to be respectful and trust that your child knows his own body signals for food.   A good rule to consider is: ‘it is your responsibility to provide healthy food and it is your baby’s choice whether he eats or not.’  And remember ‘food is fun until they are one!’   Your little one will never starve himself as long as he has access to healthy nutritious foods and at this stage milk will form the majority of his diet anyway. If your baby is a ‘late starter’ and still seems disinterested in eating family foods at eight to ten months and you feel concerned, you can ask your doctor for a blood test to check his iron levels. Chances are, if he received all his cord blood at birth, you are breastfeeding and eat a healthy diet yourself, he is active (a baby with low iron levels will probably be lethargic) and his growth and development is on track, you can relax. Just expose him to family mealtimes so he can join in socially and model your enjoyment of food when he is ready.

 

26 Comments

  1. Heather Jorre Says Reply

    HI there,
    I’m feeling such guilt right now! my son was 3 months old when I started letting him taste what I was eating for breakfast on the end of my finger. He got food envy (starting at me and crowing for more) and for the last week (he’s now 15 weeks old) he’s been having banana (and relishing it) after his usual milk feed in the morning. He scoffs it down, and has had no reaction to it, but I obviously wasn’t aware of the affect on his gut lining and the potential allergen aspect. I suspect he’s beginning to really want it now- should I stop or should I keep on going? FYI, the amount he gets is about 2 teaspoons.
    Eeeeek!

    • Pinky McKay Says Reply

      Please don’t feel guilt – ‘when we know better we do better’ is a great mantra. However, you have only given your baby tiny tastes of a low allergenic food , its been an enjoyable experience , you can slow up for a while and distract your baby until he is a bit older.No harm done.

  2. Kate Says Reply

    Since following your website I’ve since realised I shouldn’t be giving my baby rice cereal led alone any solids. He is 23weeks now and I started giving him solids a few weeks after he turned 4mths. I researched and thought this was the right thing to do. He was holding his head up well and was always looking at my husband and I eating. I’m worried now I’ve done the wrong thing? Could I have caused damage? Should I stop and just wait till he is 6mths? I have stopped the rice cereal and only feed him my home made puréed food.
    He still feeds really well on breast milk, most days he is really distracted for breast feeding but when he is hungry he feeds well.
    Also I’ve never pushed him to eat either, if he won’t take it I won’t force it. and I let him play with the spoon to chew on so he has a ‘fun’ association with food.
    I’m worried I’ve done damage though?

  3. Fiona Says Reply

    You say there is no advantage to starting solids prior to 6 months; however the Australasian Society of Clinical Immunology and Allergy recommends introducing solids between four and six months as studies have shown a reduction in allergies if started at 4 months as opposed to 6 months

    • Pinky McKay Says Reply

      The reasoning behind allergies and feeding family foods between 4 and 6 months is that breastfeeding offers protection against allergies when solids are introduced while baby is still receiving breastmilk. This still applies if babies are breastfeeding as solids are introduced after 6 months. – this is a newer study:
      introducing family foods alongside breastfeeding could reduce allergie by helping babies develop stronger immune system, according to recent University of Southampton research, published in the journal Paediatrics. (KEC Grimshaw et al. Introduction of Complementary Foods and the Relationship to Food Allergy. Paediatrics, November 1, 2013; VOLUME 132 / ISSUE 5)
      “Introducing solid foods alongside breastfeeding can benefit the immune system,” explains Dr Kate Grimshaw, leader of the research. “It appears the immune system becomes educated when there is an overlap of solids and breast milk because the milk promotes tolerogenic mechanisms against the solids.”

  4. Jenny Says Reply

    I cant seem to find any information on weaning your baby/toddler from breastfeeding. What to do, and how to do it. My bub is one year old next week, and I feel its time to stop for a number of reasons. Have you got any information please, or any links, or advice. Thanks

  5. Amy Says Reply

    Hi Pinky,

    I have a 5 month old who is very interested in watching me eat, he even ‘chews’ when I do! Should I start him on solids? I have a 2 yr old who I fed purées to as a baby but I would like to see how BLW would work for my littlest one. Is there a particular order to start foods or foods that are a no go for a baby so young?

    Thanks.

  6. Fi Says Reply

    Hi Pinky
    Great info thank you !! We are 5 months I have started to prepare for solids introduction at 6+ months. Can you suggest any books about which foods when and how?
    Thanks

  7. teeth whitening products Says Reply

    There are some other products like the Whitening Strips and the Whitening Gels which are also used widely by the people for the whitening of their teeth.

    As a general rule, for those with sensitive teeth, its best to start with
    a lower bleaching percentage. This is the word on the
    street as well as the word from the professional teeth whitening reviews doing the rounds of the Internet.

  8. Boom Beach diamonds Hack Says Reply

    Right away I am going to do my breakfast, once having my breakfast coming
    over again to read additional news.

  9. best wrinkle cream for men Says Reply

    A fascinating discussion is worth comment. I believe that
    you should write more about this topic, it might not be a taboo matter but usually
    folks don’t discuss such issues. To the next!
    Best wishes!!

  10. メンズ ファッション 帽子 アクセサリー バッグ ベルト Says Reply

    I’ve been browsing online more than 3 hours today, yet I never
    found any interesting article like yours. It’s pretty worth enough for me.
    In my opinion, if all webmasters and bloggers made good content as you did,
    the internet will be a lot more useful than ever before.

  11. Wendy Says Reply

    Hi, my little girl is 6 months. For the last 3 weeks she has seemed hungry to me. I am doing a mixture of puréed fruit but mostly baby led weaning. I have stopped cereal as I wasn’t keen on this anyway. My issue is she loves food eats it like a star and wants a lot but we seem to be suffering at night as a result!! She seems to be getting a build up of gas and tummy pain, however is not constipated. I am having to go into her over and over and over at night to pick up till passes gas out her but. I am exhausted. She is my fourth child and I have never had this issue before. We have no allergies in our family she just seems in pain, but only built up to be a problem at night. What is your suggestion, should I stop solid all together for a while, offer less and very plain food?? I am very confused as to what path to follow? Please help 🙂

    • Finglet Says Reply

      Hi Wendy,
      We have a similar problem. Nearly 7mnt old, 100% BLW & BF, ats like a trouper. Wakes regularly screaming in pain, only relived when passes wind or eventually poops. Can you let us know what you ended up doing?
      Thanks

      • Emma Says Reply

        Hi finflet
        Was there any solution to this. Im having exactly the same issue with my bub

    • Emma Says Reply

      Hi wendy
      Was there any solution to this. Im having exactly the same issue with my bub

  12. Sara T Says Reply

    Hi Pinky!

    I really enjoy your articles. I have a 7months old baby girl now. When she was 4months old she started reaching out for my food when I was eating and looking really eager to eat, specially when I was eating meat. She would get upset that I kept my plate away from her. I have gluten sensitivity and a lot of other food reactions, so my diet is very basic- organic, fresh vegetables, sweet potatoes and meat, because that is all I can tolerate.
    I really wanted to keep her exclusively on breast milk for her first 6 months, but she seemed so hungry and eager to eat that I started allowing her to eat some of my food. I have a lot of milk (too much), but maybe there wasn’t enough nutrition there? I have had a hard time healing after birth tears ( still not healed completely) and it has been a struggle to feed myself properly. I lost all my baby weight in the first few months.
    After a month of this trying to keep food away from her and her crying and getting really upset I thought that if her body is telling her to eat so strongly, then she must need it and I started feeding her when she asks for it. She is growing fast and is strong, happy and healthy.
    Now I see she wants to eat whenever I am eating and I give her some liquid from the stew or soup or I chew up my food and I give it to her – much easier than having to prepare special food for her. I wonder if the saliva in chewed-up food can have some beneficial effect for the baby’s digestion.That is surely the most natural way to feed a baby. Do you know anything about this?
    Also, when she was having more milk she would vomit and have colics a lot and now all of that seems to have passed. I wonder if she is a bit lactose intolerant? Me and her father are not, but is it possible?

    Thank you for your wonderful work!
    Sara T

  13. blessing adun Says Reply

    I need ur help have baby i an ny pls help in name God i an sign mummy

  14. Viki Says Reply

    A proctvaoive insight! Just what we need!

  15. auto insurance quotes in Los Angeles, CA Says Reply

    Ah, i see. Well that’s not too tricky at all!”

  16. http://www.ionicbathfootdetox.com/ Says Reply

    {Kathy} That sounds like a sticky situation with the grandmas. When we feel like someone is trying to take over, especially if they spend an extraordinary amount of time with our kids, it’s not good. Help doesn’t feel like help when it makes us feel inadequate.

  17. http://www.blrimages.net/ Says Reply

    Eu alternez: o zi stau si citesc, alta vad un film, alta cu treaba prin casa, dar apoi simt si nevoia de discutii si intalniri cu cei cativa prieteni. Mie in schimb nu imi plac cunostintele, adica nu mi-as sacrifica timpul liber pentru niste oameni care nu imi sunt apropiati. Sunt salbatica cu necunoscutii mai degraba. Si destul de critica, din pacate. I wish I could love people more, just as they are.

  18. http://www.reevesquadruplets.com/ Says Reply

    Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a handful of unrelated data, nevertheless seriously really worth taking a search, whoa did one particular find out about Mid East has got extra problerms at the same time

  19. http://myquotes.imahillbilly.com/saint_john_car_insurance_quotes.xml Says Reply

    Oui, c’était un piège pour voir si tout le monde suit….:-DJe plaisante, merci de me l’avoir dit !!! Je manque un peu de concentration parfois !C’est rectifié 😉

  20. http://www./ Says Reply

    It’s spooky how clever some ppl are. Thanks!

Leave a Reply